diff --git a/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenu.cs b/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenu.cs
index db8ee99..8f93b4e 100644
--- a/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenu.cs
+++ b/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenu.cs
@@ -353,7 +353,7 @@ namespace PlayerTags.GameInterface.ContextMenus
             {
                 return false;
             }
-        
+
             // The important things to make this work are:
             // 1. Allocate a temporary sub context menu title. The value doesn't matter, we'll set it later.
             // 2. Context menu item count must equal 1 to tell the game there is enough space for the "< Return" item.
@@ -383,6 +383,9 @@ namespace PlayerTags.GameInterface.ContextMenus
             var atkValues = &agentContext->ItemData->AtkValues;
             atkValues[0].UInt = 1;
 
+            // This isn't needed by the game, it's needed by ContextMenuReaderWriter which uses this to check if it's a context menu
+            m_AtkValueChangeType(&atkValues[1], FFXIVClientStructs.FFXIV.Component.GUI.ValueType.String);
+
             ContextMenuReaderWriter contextMenuReaderWriter = new ContextMenuReaderWriter(agent, agentContext->ItemData->AtkValuesCount, atkValues);
             *(&agentContext->ItemData->AtkValuesCount) = (ushort)contextMenuReaderWriter.FirstContextMenuItemIndex;
 
diff --git a/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenuReaderWriter.cs b/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenuReaderWriter.cs
index a8f159d..21f8414 100644
--- a/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenuReaderWriter.cs
+++ b/PlayerTags/GameInterface/ContextMenus/ContextMenuReaderWriter.cs
@@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ namespace PlayerTags.GameInterface.ContextMenus
                     || (int)m_AtkValues[1].Type == 38
                     || m_AtkValues[1].Type == FFXIVClientStructs.FFXIV.Component.GUI.ValueType.String;
 
-                return isStringType && m_AtkValues[1].Int != 0;
+                return isStringType;
             }
         }